Newsletter
Join the Community
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and updates
Online payroll for small businesses with household employer and nanny payroll support
SurePayroll is an online payroll service owned by Paychex, offering small business payroll processing with the backing of one of the industry's largest payroll providers. The platform covers the standard small business payroll needs — direct deposit, automatic tax filing, W-2/1099 preparation, and new hire reporting — through a streamlined interface that emphasizes simplicity over configurability. Full-service payroll handles all federal and state tax deposits and filings with error guarantee protection. A distinguishing feature is SurePayroll's household employer payroll service, designed for families paying nannies, housekeepers, caregivers, and other domestic employees — a niche most payroll providers handle poorly or not at all. The nanny payroll tier manages household worker tax obligations including Social Security, Medicare, FUTA, and state employer taxes that trip up families attempting to pay household workers legitimately. Small business plan enhancements include a 2-day direct deposit option, worker's compensation payment service, and HR center. Mobile app allows payroll runs from smartphones. Integration with QuickBooks facilitates accounting synchronization. The platform has simplified its user experience significantly in recent years. SurePayroll occupies a mid-tier position — more full-featured than bare-bones options like Patriot but less comprehensive than Gusto or OnPay's HR capabilities. Best suited for very small businesses (1–25 employees) or household employers who prioritize simplicity and reliable tax compliance over extensive HR functionality.